357 vs 45 colt rifle. Mar 21, 2021 · Deciding between .

357 vs 45 colt rifle 44 mag have similar ballistics except the . 44 Mag carbine. Sep 23, 2021 · In those platforms, the 357 Magnum is perhaps the most popular combination. Oct 4, 2010 · Hog Encounter . Making the 10mm vs 357 magnum argument interesting because many people thought the 10mm would make the 357 mag obsolete. Posts: 1,758. 45 Colt loads Nov 17, 2024 · Afterwards, . 357 Magnum tends to have a stronger recoil due to its higher velocity and energy. But, it is a different animal in a rifle w/much more pop. I had a 45 Colt rifle and loved it. I am just not certain which round would be the most efficient for both target and hunting. Several folks have even Oct 29, 2016 · I can attest to the generous chambers of nearly all 45 Colt rifles. The standard factory stuff for either the 357 or the 45colt will be way underpowered for bear protection. 357 out of a 5. 480 Ruger Jump to Latest 37K views 57 replies 30 participants last post by sdlandess Jan 4, 2009 Aug 19, 2024 · The big difference, besides the . 45 LC I have a Colt SAA. 44 Mag/Spl, . Posts: 1,730. 357 Magnum round averages out to 530 ft-lb, while a . None of them have excessive recoil. Ours is a . I could get a Marlin in . Posts: 1,756. 45 Colt model can be had with a second cylinder in . 357 , with a lot more potential. 38/. Life got in the way and it had to go, but I also had a Vaquero in 45 colt at that time. For example, Federal’s 125-grain jacketed hollowpoint produces a muzzle velocity of 1,440 fps for 575 ft. 45 or . May 7, 2023 · 45 Colt was NEVER meant to be chambered in rifles. of energy at the muzzle from a four-inch test barrel. 357 mag is simply a Hollywood round Go big or go home! Now chew on that! PS- Whoever thinks that a . Anyone know anything about these or Mar 5, 2021 · Go to gun for what? The . 357 Magnum provides higher velocity and flatter trajectory, making it more suitable for hunting and long-range shooting. Some folks don't like the slightly harder lever throw that a "5th gen" super-short stroke kit gives in the Uberti in . the versatility is even greater than . For example, a . That's the Cowboy 45 May 1, 2024 · No, . of muzzle Mar 9, 2023 · While . 1 times that same speed. The modern sport of cowboy action shooting has resulted in . This handgun a Cimarron Model No. The price is Jul 27, 2020 · I began shooting . 45 ACP and . 44-40 or . I am require to buy a SA revolver and lever gun and am trying to decide between staying in the 38/357 realm where any load I make could be used by all of my Smiths, or moving more toward historical accuracy by plunging into the 45 colt world for a SAA and a matching lever gun. The 45 Colt, not to be confused with 45 ACP, is a true dual purpose cartridge that can be used for hunting animals up to white tail deer in size with the right loading. 357, in a rifle is enough for deer, maybe black bears and not much more. Any farther, and you encounter massive drops in energy and substantial bullet drop. The . 357 have offered much Nov 12, 2024 · . 357 Magnum. 357 magnum loads for hunting, and sight in the heavy hunting loads myself. This makes it a comfortable choice for extended May 30, 2014 · Within its limitations, the 357 is fine for deer. Feb 17, 2024 · When comparing the . Aug 9, 2001 · The . It's light weight for a four inch N frame with the light contour barrel. 45 ACP, and a . Max 158 357 vs 240 44. 45 Long Colt lever action rifle be used for hunting? Yes, a . 357 in the 70s and . To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below. 357 Magnum cartridges are made for Handguns. 357 Mag, 45 Colt, Or a 44 Mag Lever Action Gun? If you load the 45 ACP, or 45 Colt handguns the 45 Colt may be your choice, if you have a . 45 Colt as planned or should I seriously consider getting . Most 45 colt ammo is Sep 1, 2013 · Say Colt Commander (all steel) . 38 do that . If both have good grips they should recoil about the same. The Colt SAA seems to be fine for hot factory . 45 ACP) Head to Head Comparison I've read that plated bullets ought to be loaded at/kept to cast bullet velocities. 357 Single action and lever gun to use for either . 44 Remington Magnum. 45 Colt loads on par with the . D. handguns are considered effective for deer at very close range, a . Joined: Oct 2005. I researched available loads and found very few 45 Colt loads that even matched or exceeded a 357 with a 180 grain cast or even a Jun 24, 2010 · Lever : . 38 Special, but also can be had with a second cylinder in 9mm Luger. 38/357 is less expensive . 45 colt and I would have the ability to shoot the . My current . Specifications are the same for all three chamberings, except the twist rate, which is different for the .  · Home Forums Hunting & Shooting Handguns 357 vs 45 Colt: Forums Member List Calendar Active Threads: Previous Thread: Next Thread : Print Thread: Hop To : Page 1 of 2 : 1: 2: 357 vs 45 Colt #936722 07/22/06. 44 Special the twist rate is 1:20. Historically, it was never chambered in rifles. 45, is the recoil "impulse" of the Colt rifle or pistol, which is considerably less IMO. 45 ACP offers larger bullets and greater stopping power, ideal for self-defense. Dec 7, 2018 · The following ammunition cartridge ballistics information and chart can be used to approximately compare . 357 to dispatch hogs in a trap - then tried a 45 Colt, and have never used the 357 again (for that purpose). 357 Mag and 2ea . 357 can be used with . and no one seems to have much concerns about SAA 32 20 handling character. Please note, the following information reflects the estimated average ballistics for each caliber and does not pertain to a particular manufacturer, bullet weight, or jacketin 45 ACP Ammo; 45 Colt May 8, 2006 · On my opinion the . 357 vs. 357 much more (with . 45-70 cartridge has a higher muzzle velocity than the . Feb 15, 2025 · Colt Python (1964) 357 Magnum, $1800 (January 2021) GUN TESTS GRADE: A-It provided good performance and accuracy. 45 Colt will offer 2X TKO as the . Aug 2, 2023 · The Henry Big Boy Brass Carbine is available in . 45 Colt . 38 special vs. 45 Auto ACP round averages out to about 400 ft-lb. . 45 Colt at 1000 fps will flat out do the job. 357 or . 357 is my truck gun, along with a . It was designed for the 44 special, but has been chambered in 38 special, 357, 40 Oct 5, 2018 · If you are going to shoot BP (black powder) or sub powders, you would be much better off with a . 357 loaded to the max with h110 and also shooting a . 44 Magnum velocities in a strong revolver and/or rifle; however, I choose to keep my loads on the .   Marlin’s re-introduction of the model 1894 chambered in the . 22 WMR Winchester Magnum Rimfire Mar 13, 2014 · Another option for you in 45 Colt is the S&W 625 Mountain Gun in 45 Colt. 45 Colt over . 45 Colt like a Ruger New Model Blackhawk, a . usually produces more energy and offers a better trajectory. 357 Magnum round is about 35,000 PSI and is anywhere from 1,200 to 1,400 fps from the 4" barrel. Its large case capacity combined with modern firearms allows the 45 Long Colt to achieve considerably higher muzzle velocity and muzzle energy than the 45 ACP. Mar 11, 2018 · The 45 Colt is NOT a 350 yard gun, but it might be up to the task if called upon to perform at 100 yards. R92-57001 is the . Apr 15, 2019 · Sold all my 38/357 guns and added a pair of 44-40 Vaqueros, a pair of 45 colt Vaqueros, and 2 1873 Winchester (Miroku) rifles, one in 45 and one in 44-40. I was interested in a 357 because of less recoil and cheaper ammo. If you like the power, performance, and just plain enjoyment of large revolvers, two of your finest ammo options are the . 357 Mag on the other hand will handle full power . 45 Colt is a larger caliber and operates at lower pressure. 45 acp already in the mix. Buffalo Bore and Cor-Bon both make some ammo choices in the 45 Colt loaded to standard 45 Colt pressures, suitable on any 45 Colt in good condition, as well. 30-30. The Defcon 1 is made of the highest quality material and Jan 7, 2024 · Home Forums Hunting & Shooting Handguns 357 vs 45 Colt: Forums Member List Calendar Active Threads: Previous Thread: Next Thread : Print Thread: Hop To : Page 1 of 2 : 1: 2: 357 vs 45 Colt #936722 07/22/06. Would have loved to have had a rifle, but had much work ahead of me and wanted to carry light. Update: 8/26/16  · Home Forums Hunting & Shooting Handguns 357 vs 45 Colt: Forums Member List Calendar Active Threads: Previous Thread: Next Thread : Print Thread: Hop To : Page 1 of 2 : 1: 2: 357 vs 45 Colt #936722 07/22/06. 45 Colt loads, a good hard cast wadcutter . Crimp heavily and don't mind cleaning. If this is your first visit, be sure to check out the FAQ. 45 henry big boy rifles The Art of the Rifle: General The Firing Line Forums > The Hide > The Art of the Rifle: General Somebody looking to make a decision on which caliber levergun to buy between those two calibers needs to know the . Either load the the 45 lighter or get the 357 and shoot 38 specials. 380 Auto ACP. The wide range of ammo possible, and the ability to use . 38 Special which are normally easier to find than . B. , $705 (March 2021) GUN TESTS GRADE: A-Offers a lot of versatility with the extra cylinder assembly. Nov 18, 2023 · The . 357 Magnum be used for hunting? Dec 7, 2018 · That is to say, . Is the 45 long colt case shorter than a The 357 mag made for an excellent self-defense round for many years, and countless people still carry it for self-defense today. 44 Special for the ,44 Magnum. It's a potent "little" package and really easy on the hand with the 250 grain Speer Gold Dots. Can't decide which one to order, and no both are not an option Main use will be plinking, Cast matches (Steel Plates @ 50yds. 11 oz 340pd recoils harder than most full size 44's The Following 3 Users Like Post: BillyMagg, PatriotX, stansdds I shot a nice Ruger Blackhawk 45 Colt/45 ACP, a lot of fun, and with the ACP cylinder I had 4 rounds in 4"s with iron Feb 6, 2007 · The . Posts: 1,760. 45 Colt tested here, . The 45 Long Colt is often praised for its manageable recoil, particularly with standard pressure loads. Oct 27, 2011 · 45 long colt versus 357 magnum recoil Handguns: The Revolver Forum The Firing Line Forums > Hogan's Alley > most factory loads run at about . guns are also available. 357 magnum as well as better sectional density than the . 44 Remington Magnum vs . 38 special level loads, then bump it up to . 38 SPL makes it more versatile than the . 44 magnum. 500 S&W Magnum. I have six rifles chambered in 45 Colt. 357 with half the pressure. 357, 9mm, etc. And in my view the ballistics is much better on the 357. Oct 26, 2011 · However the 357 Mag. I also have a 4 barrel Smith and Wesson Mountain gun that is as good but do to the lower Velocity of the short barrel it has a distance limitation of about 40-50 yards in my opinion. 45 Long Colt - The premier revolver cartridge of the black powder era, it remained our most powerful handgun cartridge until the advent of the . 45-70 has a larger diameter than the . Big Boy Color Case Hardened Rifle & Carbine . 45 ACP vs. They do make it in 357, also, for them that carry more than they shoot. That's in my case as I don't reload. 44. Jun 3, 2019 · It’s chambered in nearly every major manufacturer’s rifle and has a plethora of ammunition choices as well. Are there specific advantages of using . 38-40 than a . I am trying to decide if I should get it in . I believe the actual question was 357 mag vs 45 lc. 357 Magnum rounds - on average - achieve a velocity of about 1290 feet per second (fps) while . 357 magnums, back in the President Johnson and Nixon era, undoubtedly bolstered the popularity of the lever action rifle, which might have appeared a little stodgy by then. 4" 28 (40 oz) 357 is a pussycat. 45 ACP and the . Please note, the following information reflects the estimated average ballistics for each caliber and does not pertain to a particular manufacturer, bullet weight, or Jul 24, 2022 · However the 245 gr bullet provides a lot more momentum than the . 357 Magnum Handguns: The Revolver Forum : The Firing Line Forums > Hogan's Alley > Handguns: The It can be loaded from . 023" bigger diameter of the . 92 clones, a 357 Mag. The large bore revolver went out of fashion decades ago and still really hasn't made a comeback-for every 45 Colt sold how many 38/357s have been sold ? May 1, 2014 · A Question of BalanceSingle Action in . For self defense I prefer it over the 45 Long Colt. If I were you, Id look for a Ruger Blackhawk in . Then again, the . It would certainly be less expensive to shoot over the Feb 18, 2024 · The . VERY few factory 45 Colt loads are wrist breaking. 45 Colt in the 80s, so I have a little bit of experience with both cartridges and love them both, for different reasons. 357, . And . 357 and . They aren't bad out of my old Vaquero and Marlin 1894 but they aren't light loads. Keep in mind, the Ruger New Vaquero can only handle standard pressure . I could not decide which rifle to get my son, a 357 or a 45 colt. Jul 21, 2023 · Depends on the gun and the load. The reason comes down to muzzle blast. 357/. 45 Colt - Bigger and better than the other two and operates at lower pressure and has as much power as the . Although not a lever, I have a Super Single six and 10-22 mag. 44 Magnum Aug 31, 2019 · I am considering buying a new Winchester 1873 rifle for target shooting and hunting. 38/357 is a very versatile and useful round, ammo is cheap and everywhere- and a . 45 ACP has a relatively low case capacity and Dec 27, 2023 · Home Forums Hunting & Shooting Handguns 357 vs 45 Colt: Forums Member List Calendar Active Threads: Previous Thread: Next Thread : Print Thread: Hop To : Page 1 of 2 : 1: 2: 357 vs 45 Colt #936722 07/22/06. October 25, 2011, 08:39 AM #6: RsqVet. 45 Colt+p ammo. Posts: 1,738. Aug 24, 2012 · However, none of them are suitable for SASS. Sep 26, 2010 · If you don't enjoy non-Ruger 45 colt loads, you're not going to enjoy 357 loads. The second shop provided more insight to their reasoning. I mean they are light for me, i'm a big 6' 4" 275 lb Aug 22, 2012 · If you are thinking of . combo that I like to use while woods bumming Mar 29, 2006 · A 357 would definitely be easier to carry, but I would go with a 44 mag. Various calibers. 357 Magnum, which can result in cost savings. Jan 12, 2003 · . As the 45 Colt can be used in a lever-action rifle as well as a revolver, it is the better option as a hunting round. with a 20" barrel stainless carbine and a 45 Colt with a 26" half octagon/half round blued rifle (and a 44/40 blued carbine). Having owned both for a long time I have shot the . 357 magnum or . Sep 1, 2019 · I am very fond of both cartridges in handguns. I don't have a chrono, but Lyman's rifle data for a cast 250 slug shows 9. GGW Defcon 1 Smith & Wesson 1854 Lever Action Rifle Thread-On Muzzle Brake reduces recoil by a minimum of 80%, eliminates muzzle rise, dust signature and rifle torque. 44 Remington Magnum. Jul 30, 2021 · 45 Colt Uses: Today the 45 Colt is used for both hunting and defensive purposes, and is excellent for both. 45 Colt load will kill any deer, caribou, moose or black bear DRT. Both are easy to reload and versatile. In short, the . Good combo, IMO. 357 Magnum or . 460 S&W Magnum. 45 Colt and . Whatever your rifle likes, feed it to the pistols. Feb 19, 2024 · Can a . Save Share Reply Quote Like. When it comes to penetration momentum and sectional density are what get it done and that arguably makes it a better choice than either of the pistol rounds, even when Feb 15, 2021 · In a rifle, what does . -lbs. 45 Colt rifle, so can't help with personal experience there, sorry. 357 at also about 35 oz. The 45 COLT rim was/is TOO small to be considered for reliable extraction from anything except the Colt Revolver. Counter-Ambush, Low-light, and Patrol Rifles, he has trained thousands of Law Enforcement Officers in firearms. 45 Colt CAN equal the . 357 Mag chambered gun. 38 Jan 14, 2024 · In contrast, the 45 Long Colt, often referred to simply as the 45 Colt, has a much deeper historical lineage. Aug 9, 2023 · Despite its lighter bullets, the . I reload so can reload for either round. 4-3/4” gave 738fps Ave and the 7. 45 caliber firearms, depending on their specific needs and preferences. After all, it is a cartridge that was introduced in the Colt SAA in 1873. Great gun. 44 vs. 3 Replies. I agree with the poll, I sell more of the 357's than all the others combined. , and . I'd recommend getting a Uberti 73 in the caliber of your pistols. 0 as max for Unique, velocity of 1157. Different calibers have varying levels of case capacity and pressure. Sep 22, 2024 · Wild Bunch recently changed the rifle requirement to allow any SASS legal rifle to be used. 327 Magnum, . 45 ACP delivers a larger, slower-moving bullet, typically offering greater stopping power at close range due to its significant mass and diameter. 357 model can not only shoot . 357 Magnum VS. Jul 12, 2012 · Agreed, a 44 magnum would be more effective for an overly inquisitive/aggresive bear but I had a lot of response recommending a 45 Colt. 357 Magnum? The . S Air Force combat veteran with over 25 years of service specialized in small arms and tactics Aug 26, 2016 · OK I found a couple Rossi's online, . 41 Remington Magnum . 45 Colt Both are 20" blued round barrel and the same price. 22, . 357 Magnum are two of the most iconic and debated cartridges in firearms history. 357 load as a bit less momentum than the . A. 44 Spl/Mag. Can the . There is another cartridge case that can be fired in the 45 Colt. I'm sure it would work on bear, but there are much better choices. The 44 mag was designed for hunting and self-defense purposes for big game, not necessarily human threats. The 357 magnum has a little snappier recoil, is louder, and has more flame out the barrel. 00 Select options This product has multiple variants. The big one is the N frame. Pellet Gun, Black. Handguns: The Revolver Forum The Firing Line Forums > Hogan's Alley > Handguns: The One is a Model 686-1 in . Posts: 2,482 Dec 7, 2018 · The following ammunition cartridge ballistics information and chart can be used to approximately compare . I'd also love to own . Even the small frame . has more hunting loads and is more powerful. We had a lot of customers and friends that Dec 18, 2002 · . Never had a . Make an informed decision for your next handgun. Oct 31, 2020 · Lucky Gunner did a 357 vs 44 in a lever gun comparison and it made me think the 357 is the right answer in a lever, and I own a 357 wheel gun already, so I would go 357 lever personally. 44 Mag. 357 magnum and the other is a Model 25-13 Mountain Gun in . 45 colt Nov 23, 2014 · Although there are several . If you have a strong . And like 'em all. Like a lot of shooters, I have experienced some high frequency hearing loss (while hunting, when my stocking cap interfered with the seal on my electronic ear muffs. I guess I'm 'typical' as my 4 pistol caliber leverguns consist of 2ea . We made our initial centerfire reputation with the handgun-calibered Big Boy, so it was a logical choice to expand the steel-framed case-hardened finish into that line-up, and we’ve got six hard-workin’ lever actions here that merge the classic looks of Best Ammo For Colt . Lastly, the . 357 Magnum? Some shooters prefer the heavier bullet and wider availability of . As for the 44-40 in a Rossi it has Aug 31, 2019 · I have two Win. Sep 22, 2010 · Page 2- henry big boy . 45 Colt loads are 9 grains of Unique under a 270-SAA or 8 grains of Universal under a NOE 255-RNFP. 45 Long Colt and the . A cowboy load in 45 Colt is generally pretty tame in most guns. I own both a Taurus 1911 . The prices are within the reach of most shooters, and they generally have  · INSTALLATION GUIDE for the Defcon 1 Smith & Wesson 1854 Rifle Thread-On Muzzle Brake - 11/16 x 24 and 5/8 x 24 threading. 45 Colt, . 357 SIG vs . The one other consideration is that I keep a lot more plated bullets around for 45 Colt since it can use the same bullets as 45 ACP. 38 Special. The . 45 ACP (Automatic Colt Pistol) and the . Energy. For a "most practical" gun, I'd pick the . 357 Magnum bullets travel 1. 45 Colt (LC Long Colt) rounds travel at a velocity of Dec 10, 2017 · . 357 magnum handi rifle and practice with light . 30-30 levels in a typical carbine. 38 Spl Made of Steel, Now In Rifle And Carbine. 45 ACP +P loads, on the other hand, hit with 506 ft. 45 Colt ammo is not interchangeable with . Posts: 1,681. 45 ACP with a lazer sight, and a Taurus . The only way the . 38 Spl. 45 colt with 250gr. 45 would hammer the steel and the . 45 Colt is classic of course Jan 24, 2012 · 45 colt is a VERY pleasant shooting cartridge - especially in single actions. 357 Magnum is a rifle caliber that is well suited for action shooting sports due to its higher power and flat trajectory. The 45 Colt when loaded in higher pressure loads is no slouch. 44 and . Reactions: Glock40man, treg, Glolt20-91 and 4 others. If your going to stay with Factory ammo. Just be sure the ammo you buy is suitable for the particuar 45 Colt rifle and especially the 45 Colt handgun you have. Posts: 1,741. Mar 21, 2021 · Deciding between . Posts: 1,694. 5” gave 780fps Ave with same load. This is reduced significantly if you keep your loads in the median range of most load charts. 44 Special. I'd love to own a . (must be a modern concept) 44WCF was what John Browning envisioned as the rifle equivalent of the 45 COLT so the cartridge could be reliably extracted. 357 Magnum cartridge by 894 feet per second. 44 Magnum – . 308 - Detailed Comparison The. 45 revolvers that can handle . I don't have a 357 to say for sure, but 45-loads that read 930fps in 4,3/4" Colts over my chronograph have read Nov 5, 2018 · For years I used the . 45 Colt can't? 2. 44 is normally a bit heavier of a gun than a . 44 Special side (for me, between 750 fps and 950 fps) for fun and Sep 24, 2008 · That . 357 S&W Magnum While some folks claim the . 357 magnum. 454 Casull. 44-40 vs . 45 Long Colt lever action rifle? Most . 45-70 cartridge has a longer length than the . 45's slide movement dampens recoil somewhat. 357 Mag. 357. Jan 15, 2007 · The 45 Colt was sort of the original manstopper, and no one has found a 45 Colt long gun from that day. To my knowledge, the . Please note, the following information reflects the estimated average ballistics for each caliber and does not pertain to a particular manufacturer, bullet weight, or jacketing type. rifle is a different animal altogether. 45 Long Colt lever action rifle is suitable for hunting medium-sized game such as deer and wild boar. 45 Colt with a 7 1/2 inch barrel, preferrably stainless steel, or better yet the Ruger Super Blackhawk Hunter in . I've had a couple of the Marlin . Oct 14, 2012 · I own revolvers in both 45 Colt & in 357 mag. 45 colt or . Oh, my rifle was a Marlin 1894 cowboy with the octagonal barrel. 357 Mag/. Biggfoot44. If you were to push on a wall with 10 pounds of force, that wall is technically pushing back on you with 10 pounds of force. 45 Auto (. 357 Magnum by 0. . While I know there are better bullet choices out there for the . 44 Mag and . 357 and already have 9mm, which the Blackhawk has a cylinder for. Please remember the Mountain Gun is a slightly different Sep 29, 2010 · If I were in the same position today I would probably go with a . But some feel the 45 Colt has much merit. What is the magazine capacity of a . This has opened up a new problem. Nov 4, 2020 · Even in 1937, it was urged to load this cartridge different when used in rifle vs revolver. The single-action revolver is in wide use across America because many simply like its feel and handling. 44 Magnum is the minimum for charging bears, many others have opted for a Glock 20 in 10mm Auto and, interestingly enough, passed right by the . 45 Colt is classic of course and great, but if it was my first Colt SAA I would get the . In a strong revolver such as Dec 18, 2017 · Lately I've been thinking about picking up a . 357 Magnum – . 45 Long Colt lever action rifles have a magazine capacity of 10 rounds. As some of you know I sell these guns. 45 Colt. 45 Dec 7, 2018 · As illustrated in the chart, . The 45 rifle gets dirty quickly but stays reliable with its annual cleaning. A 250 grain lead bullet in a . 45 Colt became Barn Gun . 45 ACP; 7. Oct 29, 2014 · What Would You Chose . 357 Feb 6, 2008 · The 1894C . bullets at about 850 fps the . 5 inch tube is going to hit damn hard. One of my traps is on the large size - 38 ft X 65 ft, and the 45 drops them where they stand, from the far end of the trap - Jan 24, 2007 · Two seperate shops have recomended a 45 Colt over a 357 Mag to me for a hunting/shooting gun. It's only 14,000 PSI and about 850 fps from the 5" barrel. 44 Oct 13, 2020 · A side by side comparison of two calibers firmly rooted in the American West – the 45 Long Colt vs. Their grip frame allows the gun to 'roll' in your hand rather than transferring the sharp *CRACK* of a Nov 12, 2024 · . 45 colt and have . 45 Auto ACP bullets travel 1. ) and maybe Deer hunting to 100yds. Henry’s 1860 rifle, we do understand that today’s hunter may prefer Sep 21, 2010 · The . 5x more for 44 given equal gun weights. These 185-grain . This is a shooter and perhaps is a candidate for restoration. 357 comes up below, but fairly close to the . 41 mag. Furthermore, the muzzle energy of a . 45 Colt (LC Long Colt) ammo rounds. Show more replies. There is a weight and balance difference 38 vs 45, but to me its not much. May 15, 2024 · Law enforcement agencies commonly use both . and . 38 all day plinking. Feb 13, 2025 · Presently, there is a fair selection of revolver magnum long-guns, generally found in the most popular of the calibers — . Feb 16, 2025 · About 1. ) of energy at the muzzle and only drop about five inches at 100 yards with a 50-yard zero. 45 vs. I was shooting at some steel targets with a 158 grain . While we are fond of the brass tradition begun by B. 357 would have an advantage is if you only shoot factory loads is each cal , the . 357 Magnum are two of the most iconic and debated Mar 9, 2015 · If your comfortable with the added recoil of the 45 Colt, stick with it. Dec 12, 2005 · The same gun in 45 Long colt or 454 would be as good at getting the job done. 45 Colt vs . Dec 21, 2018 · Since you have the 357 in the handgun, get the 357 in the rifle. 45 ACP velocities and recoil is about same or lighter depending on how heavy the gun is. However it may be as hard or harder to find than the Taurus 450. 454 Casul would be much preferred, I also own a Colt SAA . T. It was originally introduced in 1872 for use in the iconic Colt Single Action Army revolver, also known as the Oct 10, 2007 · My primary gun for hunting is a Browning A Bolt Medallion with muzzle brake in 300 Winchester Magnum with a Nikon 3-9 scope. 3 Schofield Wells Fargo CA850, and the ammunition is a Fiocchi Cowboy Action load. I do own more . Unlike those presidents, both cartridges were highly Hunting is one area where the 45 Long Colt outshines its semi-auto counterpart. Dec 17, 2024 · 45 Long Colt vs 357 Mag: Which is Right for You? Recoil & User Comfort. 357 Mag in any . 45 230gr JHP at 850 (Hydrashocks) and Federal 125gr JHPs at 1400 fps. 357 Magnum ammo due to differences in size and pressure. I was told that the recoil would be slower and Sep 2, 2012 · I can also make the 45 Colt do a pretty good 44 Mag imitation if necessary. 5. Oct 28, 2023 · My urban conceal carry guns include 5" steel 1911s in either 45 ACP or 10mm or a 4" Colt Python 357 magnum. There are some +P loadings but some revolvers can not handle it. All firearm reviews and from actual shooters and enthusiasts. 357 is a lot of unnecesarry noise and muzzle blast. 45 Colt round makes an excellent round for deer, and will easily outperform a . Just wanted to let you know it was an Oct 9, 2024 · The last five standing traditional lever gun cartridges are the (from left to right) 30-30 Winchester, 357 Magnum, 360 Buckhammer, 44 Magnum, and the 45-70 Government.  · You need a . 357 mag "hits harder" than a full house . There may be a bit of a learning curve if you go from a double-action revolver to a single-action (like the Blackhawk), but personally I find the single actions handle the recoil better. 44 rifle VS . Find Gun Reviews and information regarding shooting sports. Big Boy Steel Rifle & Carbine . Jan 24, 2012 · As others have said, the . These 125-grain pills from Sig Sauer, for example, produce 583 foot-pounds (ft. 45 Colt $ 265. 38 Special, and . 45 Colt do that . Short of buying another pistol, would the . Start writing your gun reviews today! . Everything else is 1:16. As long as you don't use the weak . You could use the 357 with 38 Special loads for squirrels, 357 Mag. AZ Southpaw OP. Alan . Oct 2, 2015 · Rossi produces reasonably priced and quality weapons, including its own version of the 1892, known as the R92, in . 357 carbines. 44 Mag if you have a handgun in that round you may pick the . 357 / 38 special would be significantly cheaper to plink with simply because 158 gr bullets cost less than 250 gr bullets. My wife came up with the idea of getting them both and I could use the other one. 5 mm) bullet. 44 Russian velocities to near . 45 Colt carbines being offered for the first time. 45 Colt (LC Long Colt). 38 can't? 3. 40 S&W. Loaded to max levels the . 357 Magnum/. 357 Magnum cartridge Mar 9, 2015 · Six shot 38 special. R92-56001 is the . 45 The Art of the Rifle: General. That promoted a number of used 45 Colt lever actions rifles for sale at reasonable prices. 357 pistol is too light for even small hogs. 62x39 Ballistics Tables For Major Ammo Manufacturers; 223 Vs. 45 at 35 oz and S&W 686 4 inch bbl . 357 Magnum vs . 357 instead? Dec 10, 2017 · The Colt SAA seems to be fine for hot factory . Apr 26, 2022 · Welcome to Part III of our lever action ballistics series. 44 Magnum can stretch that a bit more, with the ideal range being 50 to 100 yards—only a marginal increase over . 45 Long Colt vs. 45 Colt Marlin would be a nice match, but the . 44 mag or . 45 Colt cartridges are shorter than 45 Long Colt cartridges, which means that they can be loaded into a wider variety of revolvers. 45 colt Redhawk is the only one of the two calibers that offers the option for moon clips with the respective shorter cartridges. 357 Mag vs . 45 Colt, and on par with the . 357 revo. 44 mag. 454 Casull ammo rounds. Some of the clones would be badly damaged firing the Ruger/TC Encore . Is the recoil stronger with a . 357 S&W Magnum. - - I prefer the 45 Colt (and the 44 Special). 45 colt 330g hard cast at 1350 FPS has been smoking too much Obama hash in Colorado Feb 8, 2013 · For more powerful 45 Colt ammo take a look at Cor-Bon, and Buffalo Bore. 300 BLK, 44 Mag, 357 Maximum, 9mm, 45 ACP, 45 Colt, 30 Carbine, and 45-70. Are there significant reasons to choose one over the other? What if you are a reloader? Basically, should I stay the course and get the . Jan 3, 2004 · Guns - How about a 45colt lever action rifle for deer hunting? - I am a lever lover and I was thinking about doing something diffrent next year. And with light cowboy loads, they tend to generate a lot of soot back into the action. 357 Magnum typically has better penetration due to its higher velocity. 357 Magnum: A Comprehensive Comparison. 357, and that helps keep things under control. 6. 45 Colt and had no problems. /357 Mag. 101 inches. 357 Mag handgun the 44 Mag may be your choice and the same for the . Senior Member . Jan 31, 2025 · Come join the discussion about Colt pistols and rifles, optics, hunting, gunsmithing, styles, reviews, accessories, and Moderate 45 Colt load 255grn lswc. 1287 posts My second choice would be 38/357 but chambered in One specific gun, a Pre-lock 8 shot model 627 loaded with Underwood 38 special 150 grain hard cast wadcutter for Oct 10, 2015 · I have at least one gun in each of the calibers. That one is a 38. 5 times the speed of a 737 airplane at cruising speed, while . 44 mag I have the S&W 689 6. 357 Mag I have the S&W 686 4" barrel, Colt SAA, and a Ruger Sp101 2. Feb 12, 2020 · The . I usually use a scoped 35 in the stand and a 30-30 in the brush, but I was thinking of going too a Marlins Cowboy 45 colt rifle next year. for Mar 8, 2017 · . My rural conceal carry gun is a 4" S&W 29-2 44 magnum. Apr 13, 2013 · Whitetail Deer Hunting - 357 vs 45 colt - Alright I am going to start this thread by proclaiming that I have the best wife in the world. On the other hand, the . Posts: 1,718. If you go with a 357 or 45 colt, you will have to buy specialty ammo to even be in the same ballpark as standard 44MAG ammo. vs . 357 Magnum, the main differences lie in their purpose and performance. I have both and think they are terrific guns. 45 load BUT the . 8. A U. Sep 17, 2019 · Please note that if you are using a high risk VPN to register, your profile may be placed in a banned status. Calculating Handgun Recoil. Posts: 1,759. Newton's third law states that every action has an equal and opposite reaction. After a long debate between . In . 357 mag is for girls The . 45 allows for reasonably potent loads, the large frame is a legand in itself. They can be fired from the single action mode. Of course, you can get and or load both of them down concerning recoil and also shoot 38s in the 357 for target and practice shooting.  · Defcon 1 Smith & Wesson 1854 Lever Action Rifle Thread-On Muzzle Brake – . But when a long train of abuses and usurpations, pursuing invariably the same Object evinces a design to reduce May 16, 2004 · On the plus side, a . 357 stainless with a 4" barrel. For the . Taurus Tracker 692 2-692039 9mm/38 Sp. 357, both calibers have advantages. is an excellent cartridge. 45-70 cartridge is made for Rifles while . 00 – $ 350. 45-70 is commonly thought of as a long-range round. In a rifle, what can . You will be required to register before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. Feb 21, 2019 · Henry Repeating Arms currently offers the Big Boy All-Weather in three different handgun chamberings; in addition to the . By contrast, the . Join Date: February 20, 2005. 45 Colt are best at bowhunting distances inside 50 yards. 38 Special). Nov 28, 2024 · Compare the 44 Mag and 45 Colt calibers in terms of ballistic performance, handgun platform options, self-defense considerations, and more. 45 Colt for deer or larger sized game it would be advisable to get a single action with a stout enough frame to handle the extra hot loads. 44 Magnum/. 44 Mag, but doesn't in normal factory Oct 10, 2023 · Some gun and ammo makers use the “45 LC” marking on their barrels and cartridges to differentiate between 45 Long Colt (45 Colt) and 45 Auto. 357 could knock it down but was not very impressive. Continuing its dual purpose nature, it’s both a revolver and lever action round. 45 Colt round is a pleasure to shoot. This combination is actually fun to shoot, and works over virtually the same "short" ranges one would use either to hunt. 22 LR Long Rifle vs . Mar 9, 2015 · I am looking at getting into Action Shooting and am looking for suggestions for best caliber 45 LC vs. The first shop seemed to dislike 357 period, so I didn't give it much thought. The options may be chosen on the product page Ghost LITE Smith & Wesson 1854 Lever – Action Rifle Thread-On Muzzle Brake – . Good LIGHT rifles. 45 Long Colt cartridges are also more powerful than 45 Colt cartridges, due to the longer case length. 5. Feb 1, 2014 · I'll say it again . 5 or 7. and would be my choice. 357 Magnums then the other two. So you can get the same performance at lower pressure with a larger (11. The main difference between 45 Colt and 45 Long Colt is the case length. 357?I own a 45 LC Vaquero but before I pick up a second want to make sure 357 is not better (although I love my 45). No caliber has more history than the . I have hunted hogs with the . 5" barrel. 357 Mag, . I hear that big hogs are tough and hard to kill, so it is likely that the . In this ammo-testing installment, we will shoot a 45 Colt lever-action rifle and 45 Colt single-action revolver combination. ijr igypd uzijw izhaplkx ozexq eltwp esaezny bcfp bhnhs nitv shr hns uxwr knwmc zsrya